This is a bad headshot…
…and this is a good one.
These photos were taken minutes apart, and I shot the one on the left (as much as it pained me) to illustrate a point. Objectively speaking, it’s a bad picture—the sort you get when it’s time for a new headshot, so your coworker grabs his phone and tells you to stand over there and smile. It’s an awkward experience for both of you, and the result is crude and clumsy and unfit for professional use.
What’s wrong with it, exactly? Geez, where to begin! The light is uneven across the face, but not in a way that’s intentional, interesting, or pleasing, and his eyes are dark and dead. His skin, freshly tanned (burned?) from a trip to Mexico, has a slight “hand me a glass of milk ‘cause I just ate a whole jalapeño” look to it. The background is a bit bright relative to the subject and overly detailed, and both the pose and expression are stiff. Even the composition needs work. In short? It’s a snapshot, not a headshot.
The second picture is the sort of result you can expect from a professional photographer. Most of the fix was done at the time of capture using supplemental lighting on the subject (notice in particular how the catchlights bring the eyes back from the dead), and proper camera settings for a good exposure and blur amount on the background. A little posing direction and easy conversation kept the subject from looking wooden, like the bespectacled telephone pole in the first image. Afterward, in the edit, the red skin tone was adjusted and some other light retouching was done, including global and local adjustments to color, contrast, etc.
If your headshot looks more like the first image than the second, it’s probably time for not just an update, but an upgrade. The way we present ourselves matters, especially in a professional context—a headshot on LinkedIn or your company’s website is often the first look anyone gets at you. Which above version would you rather they see?
If I can help, please send an email my way. Or contact another photographer you may know! Either way, the important thing is to shelve that current headshot if it’s working against you. Good luck out there, and thank you for reading.